Dress coding in schools can be a sensitive topic, with many students and parents feeling that it restricts their freedom of expression. In the US, for example, dress codes are governed by Title IX, a federal law that prohibits sex-based discrimination in education.
Schools often implement dress codes to promote a safe and respectful learning environment. According to a study, schools that enforce dress codes report a 30% decrease in bullying incidents.
Dress codes can also be seen as a way to reduce distractions in the classroom. A survey of teachers found that 75% of them believe that dress codes help students focus on their studies.
However, some argue that dress codes can be overly restrictive, stifling self-expression and individuality. A study found that students who feel their freedom of expression is restricted are more likely to experience depression and anxiety.
Take a look at this: Matrix Error Codes
Dress Code Policies
School dress codes can be a sensitive topic, and it's essential to understand the policies in place. Dress and grooming policies based on gender stereotypes are not uncommon.
The American Civil Liberties Union highlights the issue, and it's crucial to know your rights. You can find a handy fact sheet on school dress codes and grooming policies, gender identity, and self-expression on the ACLU website.
Schools may have different policies for boys and girls, which can be unfair and discriminatory. Dress codes that restrict certain types of clothing or hairstyles based on gender are a concern.
The ACLU encourages you to share your story if you've experienced dress code policies that treat people differently based on gender stereotypes. By speaking out, you can help create a more inclusive environment.
Recommended read: Unlock Iphone without Codes
School Dress Code Standards
School dress code standards can be quite confusing, but it's worth understanding what's considered acceptable by your school's rules. No two school districts' dress codes are the same.
Some schools have specific restrictions on sleeveless tops, like requiring straps to be at least 2½ or three adult fingers wide. For example, in North Carolina's Porter Ridge High School, sleeveless tops are only allowed if the straps meet this width requirement.
Bare midriffs are often not allowed, with some schools stating that exposed backs, shoulders, and midriffs are not permitted. Pennsylvania's Harrisburg School District is one such example.
Necklines that expose too much cleavage or chest are also often prohibited, with some schools even banning cleavage altogether.
Standards
Schools have their own unique dress code standards, and it's essential to check the school handbook to see what's allowed and what's not. No two school districts' dress codes are the same.
Public schools have to follow certain guidelines to be compliant, but private and charter schools have more flexibility. The ACLU outlines some of these guidelines on its website.
School dress codes can be restrictive, with some banning hoodies or leggings, while others permit jeans with holes. The reasons behind these restrictions can be discriminatory.
It's always a good idea to check your school's handbook to see what the current dress code restrictions are.
Uniform Requirements
Schools can promote a voluntary student uniform policy, which a number of schools in RI have instituted. This way, students have the freedom to choose whether or not to wear uniforms.
The ACLU believes that forcing students to wear uniforms infringes on their right to free speech and expression. This is because uniforms restrict students' individuality, expression, and creativity.
Schools that require uniforms often cite the idea that it prepares students for the workplace, but unlike students, adults have the freedom to decide where they will work. If they choose to, they can easily avoid jobs that don't require uniforms.
Research shows that uniforms do not reduce bullying, and in fact, one study shows that they can even increase the average number of assaults by about 14 per year in the most violent schools.
Tight or Revealing
Tight or revealing clothing is often outrightly banned in many school dress codes.
These bans are almost exclusively geared toward female-identifying students.
Staff more frequently perceive outfits worn by students with more voluptuous bodies as revealing and inappropriate.
The Porter Ridge High School handbook states that if you're wearing yoga pants, leggings, or stretch pants, the shirt must be at fingertip length.
This rule is an example of how schools try to regulate clothing that's deemed too tight or revealing.
It's questionable at the very least and sexually perverse at the worst to target female-identifying students with these kinds of dress codes.
Many teachers fight back against these dress codes by refusing to implement them in their classrooms.
There is still a long way to go in terms of creating fair and inclusive school dress code standards.
Undergarments
Undergarments can be a tricky area in school dress codes, and it's essential to understand the specific rules. Some schools prohibit visible underwear, including bra straps showing under tank tops or underwear beneath baggy pants.
In the Oregon NOW Model Student Dress Code, undergarments showing through rips and holes in clothing are usually prohibited. However, it's worth noting that showing undergarment waistbands and straps is not considered a violation.
Some schools have different rules regarding undergarments, so it's crucial to check the specific dress code of your school.
Student Religious Freedom and Cultural Expression
School dress code standards can be a sensitive topic, especially when it comes to student religious freedom and cultural expression. The First Amendment of the Constitution mandates that public schools remain neutral on the subject of religion.
School administrators often misinterpret this and attempt to curtail all religious expression. Students have been suspended or otherwise disciplined for wearing rosary beads, crucifixes, yarmulkes, headscarves/hijabs, and pentagrams.
The Constitution's neutrality clause is meant to protect students' right to express their faith, but some schools have gotten it wrong. This has led to students being punished for wearing symbols of their faith.
Schools have also attempted to ban students from wearing hairstyles that reflect their ethnic and or cultural heritage. Some school dress codes have prohibited “extreme or distracting” hairstyles, which can include “dreadlocks, cornrows, twists, or mohawks” and “afros more than two inches in length.”
These policies are frequently denounced for singling out African-American students. Students are also subjected to having their hair inspected or suspended for wearing box braids.
The issue of head coverings is also a concern. While body modifications are becoming more prevalent, some schools still have conservative dress codes that take a traditional approach. Unfortunately, these rules are rooted in moral discrimination.
Safety and Distractions
School dress codes are often written with safety in mind, aiming to prevent gang activity, theft, and violence by eliminating clothing that can hide weapons or make students more accident-prone.
Some schools ban apparel like spiked jewelry and wallet chains because of the potential damage they pose to school property.
Schools may also justify dress code regulations as a way to maintain a distraction-free learning environment, but these rules can be used to target certain students based on their religion, race, culture, gender identity, or body modification expressions.
Courts have established that schools can regulate dress to prevent clear and present dangers to students' health and safety, or to prevent interference with school work or classroom disorder.
Safety
School dress codes often have safety in mind, aiming to prevent gang activity and theft by eliminating clothing that can hide weapons or make students more accident-prone.
Specific rules may ban clothing that poses a risk, such as spiked jewelry and wallet chains that can damage school property.
Some schools prohibit clothing that can be used to hide weapons, like certain types of jackets or pants with hidden pockets.
This is done to create a safer environment for students, particularly in areas with high crime rates or gang activity.
The Distraction Discussion
Schools often justify strict dress code regulations by citing the need to maintain a distraction-free learning environment. Unfortunately, these regulations can be used to target certain students based on their religion, race, culture, gender identity, and body modification expressions.
In 1972, the RI Commissioner of Education held that school districts are limited to regulating the dress of pupils to situations where it presents a clear and present danger to the student's health and safety, causes an interference with school work, or creates a classroom or school disorder.
Schools can't just ban any type of clothing they deem distracting. For example, courts are more likely to defer to a school's determination if the clothing is disruptive or interferes with school activity, but not if it has a social, political, or religious message.
In the case of the ACLU winning a lawsuit against a school policy that banned students from wearing breast cancer awareness bracelets, it's clear that schools need to be more thoughtful in their dress code regulations.
Restrictions and Bans
Schools can ban gang-related clothing and accessories, but the specific items prohibited will vary depending on the gang activity in your area, such as shirts with printed mottos or pictures that promote gang affiliation.
Some schools also ban bulky clothing, including heavy coats, trench coats, and baggy clothing, to prevent students from hiding weapons. This is the case at Thompson Middle School, where students can't wear "extremely baggy" clothing.
In some schools, shirts must be tucked in at the waist for all grades, like in The Saint Lucie County School District, to maintain a professional look and prevent concealed weapons.
Bans on Gang-Related
Schools can ban gang-related clothing and accessories, but the specific items prohibited will vary depending on the gang activity in your area. For example, Gloucester High School prohibits shirts with printed mottos or pictures that promote gang affiliation.
Schools must clearly and reasonably draft policies regarding gang-related apparel. A federal appeals court struck down a school policy as unconstitutionally vague because it was not specific about what was not allowed.
Schools can't bar you from wearing clothing just because they disapprove of the message, but they can prohibit indecent or disruptive messages. The RI ACLU successfully challenged a student's suspension for wearing a rock band t-shirt with the numerals "666" on it.
Schools have differing opinions on what constitutes a disruption. A Virginia court ruled that a school could ban a t-shirt with the phrase "Drugs Suck" as "vulgar."
Loose Shirt Bans
Some schools take a more specific approach to regulating student attire, focusing on shirts that are too loose. Shirts must be tucked in at the waist for students in all grades at schools like The Saint Lucie County School District.
This guideline is meant to promote a more professional look, and it's also intended to prevent students from concealing items in the waistband of their pants or skirts.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long have dress codes in schools been around?
Dress codes in schools have been around since 1969, when the U.S. Supreme Court established the first school dress code law. Since then, dress code policies have evolved to promote a safe and respectful learning environment.
Sources
- https://www.aclu.org/news/womens-rights/4-things-public-schools-can-and-cant-do-dress-codes
- https://www.aclutx.org/en/publications/dressed-express-how-dress-codes-discriminate-against-texas-students-and-must-be-changed
- https://www.lovetoknow.com/parenting/teens/school-dress-codes
- https://www.youthrights.org/issues/student-rights/dress-codes-and-uniforms/
- https://www.riaclu.org/en/know-your-rights/know-your-rights-students-school-dress-codes
Featured Images: pexels.com